I Once Stopped After Book 1 of "The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo" | Re-reading Through Book 4 Changed My Mind (No Spoilers)

* This article contains affiliate links (PR). If you purchase through a link, the site operator may receive a referral fee. The opinions here are the author's own, based on actually buying and using the product.

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, the first book in Stieg Larsson's "Millennium" series, is a work I once walked away from partway through the series. Years ago, after reading the first book, I heard that "the author has died, and the series was apparently left unfinished." If I was going to spend time on a long series, I wanted to read one whose story properly reaches an ending. So I decided not to continue.

But this time, when I re-read the first book, it was just as good as I remembered. So this time I didn't stop — I went on to the second and third books, and even the fourth, written by a different author. And my old impression — "it's unfinished, so there's no point reading it" — changed completely. Larsson's own three books have a coherence as one big story, and the fourth book that followed, though by another author, had inherited the series' appeal.

In this article, without touching on the culprit, the tricks, or the ending at all (no spoilers), I will write about why I — someone who once left after book 1 — came back to the series after re-reading it. I hope it helps anyone who has been avoiding this series for the same reason I once did.

What I knew before reading, and a synopsis of the setup only

The protagonist is Mikael Blomkvist, a journalist for a monthly magazine. When he finds himself in a corner after a certain incident, an elder of one of Sweden's wealthiest families asks him to reinvestigate the disappearance of a girl from the family, decades ago. As the investigation proceeds, Mikael meets Lisbeth Salander, a young woman with a genius-level talent for investigation, and the two of them confront the old case together — that is the setup. Lisbeth, with her dragon tattoo, has an overwhelming presence from the moment she appears.

Series basics (no spoilers)

The "Millennium" series began as a trilogy by the Swedish author Stieg Larsson. Book 1, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo; book 2, The Girl Who Played with Fire; book 3, The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest — these are Larsson's works. After Larsson's death, the series was taken over by David Lagercrantz, and book 4, The Girl in the Spider's Web, was published (and further sequels have followed since). It is a worldwide bestseller that has also been adapted into films.

The word "unfinished," which had bothered me at the time, is easier to understand if you take it to mean that Larsson had plans for a much longer series. At the very least, the three published books are not fragments meant only to leave readers hanging. Reading through them this time, I really felt how the larger current that isn't visible from book 1 alone grows thicker in books 2 and 3. Of course, I won't touch on the specific endings of each volume here.

Why I stopped after book 1, back then

Looking back, my younger self wasn't dissatisfied with the work itself. The problem was the anxiety that "the story might end up left floating in midair." A long series asks for the reader's time, volume after volume, even after you finish one book. And the more gripping it is, the more attached you become to the characters — so the information that "the author has died and it apparently won't be completed" was more than enough to stop me from opening the next book.

But that judgment was also one I had formed from information I had before reading. From book 1 alone, you can't tell how big a story this series really is. This time, by re-reading and going further, I felt there is a considerable difference between "staying away because it might be unfinished" and "reading through all three books."

Re-reading it, I first felt the strength of book 1

If I had to sum up in one phrase why this series draws me in, it would be that "it fuses realistic developments with developments that exceed expectations." Because there is a grounded process — reporting, investigation, the accumulation of documents — when the story moves in a direction beyond what you expected, it still feels convincing. Rather than lining up flashy events one after another, the flow of "because they investigated this far, they arrive at this fact" pulls the reader in.

The characters are distinctive, too. Mikael and Lisbeth in particular are contrasts in both personality and method, and the fact that the two of them work on the same investigation is itself a highlight. It doesn't rely only on Lisbeth's intensity; because Mikael has the tenacity and humanity of a journalist, the story gains depth. With characters drawn like this, you find yourself wanting to follow not just the case itself, but "what will these two do next?"

The pleasure of re-reading is a little different from a first read. The first time, you turn the pages driven by "what happens next?"; on a re-read, you can check how the relationships and small details placed early on connect to later developments. Book 1 has an introduction and a build-up that mystery lovers will relish. I think the reason its energy didn't fade on re-reading is that it isn't just about surprise — the build-up of the setup itself is fascinating.

The appeal of book 1 as "the entrance to the series," seen on re-reading

Back then I read book 1 as a standalone work, but this time I read it as "the entrance to the whole series." Then the character relationships and themes of book 1 also start to look like thick pillars leading into the later books. Of course, book 1 can be read as a mystery on its own. But when you take the sequels into view, the way you feel the characters' appeal changes. The pleasure of "what kind of fight will this character put up next?" increases.

With books 2 and 3, the series suddenly becomes much bigger

In books 2 and 3, I couldn't look away from the grand revenge drama and team battle that, despite being an epic, never drags. Works that grow in scale tend to become scattered as settings and related characters multiply, but this series has the relationships and the accumulation of investigation built in book 1, so even as the story expands, its axis doesn't waver easily. Since readers already know the characters, the run-up needed to enter new developments is short, and the excitement keeps going.

That "team battle" feeling is also a big part of these two books' appeal. It isn't that one person is all-powerful; people with their own abilities and positions move, and information connects. That accumulation becomes the momentum toward the climax. I'll keep the specific developments hidden, but beyond the interest of individual scenes, the feeling of "everyone together crashing into one huge wall" strengthened the satisfaction of reading a long novel.

There is also heat as a revenge drama. Rather than simply stirring emotions, because you know the events so far and the characters' backgrounds, you can understand the weight of their actions. The size of the series, hard to imagine when I had only read book 1, was something I could only really feel after going through books 2 and 3. This is the part where I most regretted having stopped at book 1 back then.

Book 4, by a different author, inherits it safely

Before reading book 4, I did have anxieties. When the author changes, the quirks of the prose and the way characters are handled change too. The worry — "what if it's something else entirely, just borrowing the name of a series I loved?" — is unavoidable with series fiction. Having actually read it, there are places in the details that catch my attention. I won't say it's exactly the same as the previous books, and there are scenes where the differences stand out.

Even so, my conclusion is that it felt like a safe inheritance of the series. What matters, I think, is not perfectly imitating the predecessor's prose, but preserving the core of the characters readers want to meet again, and moving the story forward. The main characters' appeal is undiminished, and the pull to keep reading remains. So if you enjoyed the series through book 3, there is no need to avoid book 4 just because the author changed — that is my impression this time.

Rather, my old self, who had stopped at book 1, had never verified — on the basis of the single fact that "the author died" — either the completeness of Larsson's three books or the quality of the successor's work. Reading them in order this time, I could truly feel that the series had not simply stopped.

Conclusion

My old self never went past book 1, based only on the information that "the author has died and it's apparently unfinished." But this time — re-reading book 1, passing through the grand revenge drama and team battle of books 2 and 3, and reading up to book 4 by the new author — my impression changed clearly. Millennium was not a series that stopped partway; Larsson's three books have a definite expanse, and there are sequels that inherit their appeal to enjoy as well.

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is a book that offers both the excitement of a first read and the discoveries of a re-read. If, for the same reason as me, you've been avoiding going past book 1, please try going at least as far as book 2. The true size of the series becomes visible from there.

* The eBook links (Rakuten Kobo and Kindle) go to the combined edition containing both the upper and lower volumes. Prices and stock change. Please check the latest information on the linked page before purchasing.